On September 2, 2025, The Washington Post published an article (Bogage, 2025) reporting that E. J. Antoni, Donald Trump’s nominee for head of the Bureau of Labor Statistics, had “shared a controversial scientific theory of inherent differences in intellect between men and women” to interns at the Heritage Foundation, where he works. [Update, September 30, 2025: The White House has withdrawn Mr. Antoni’s nomination.]

What is the “controversial scientific theory”? The greater male variability hypothesis, which states that for many traits (not just IQ) males have a higher standard deviation than females. This higher variability in males usually leads to greater representation in the high and the low ends of a distribution. This is the same scientific idea that led to Lawrence Summer’s resignation as president of Harvard in 2005 when he mentioned it at a conference.
Despite labeling the greater male variability hypothesis as “controversial,” the article’s author states that studies have “varying results”. But the three studies he lists (Baye & Monseur, 2016; Deary et al., 2003; Gray et al., 2019) all support the claim of higher male variability in IQ or educational achievement test scores. The author even uses the word “confirmed” twice!
Because of this acknowledgement, and support for the greater male variability hypothesis in my own data from the RIOT IQ test (Warne, 2025), I wrote a letter to the editor at The Washington Post. The editor declined to publish it, and so I am publishing it here with an added image and caption.
Letter
Regarding the September 2, 2025, article reporting the remarks about male and female IQ variability by E. J. Antoni (“Trump’s BLS nominee discussed controversial theory on gender IQ with interns”):
Among psychologists, the “greater male variability hypothesis” is not “controversial” at all. Higher male variability in intelligence has been accepted as a mainstream finding on intelligence for decades and has been replicated with many intelligence tests. For example, on my own Reasoning and Intelligence Online Test (RIOT), males had scores that were 14.8% more variable, which caused more women to have IQ scores between 81 and 115 and more men to have scores outside of this range, even though the two groups’ average IQs differed by only a trivial amount (0.69 points).

The greater male variability hypothesis is a parsimonious explanation of the fact that there are more males in the extremes of intellectual accomplishment. Indeed, greater male ability is not just found in IQ. Males are also more variable in personality traits, height, weight, and many other characteristics and behaviors. Greater male variability also occurs in many life outcomes that are relevant to economists; there are more male billionaires and more homeless males, for example. There is also more variability in the number of hours males work than females. Greater male variability is even found in many physical and behavioral observations in non-human mammals.
These facts are well established in psychology and biology. To call greater male variability “controversial” greatly misrepresents the scientific consensus about sex differences. It also poisons the well of discourse and makes it more difficult to incorporate scientific research into important societal discussions about economic outcomes, special education, women’s representation in the sciences, and other topics.
Based on the reporting of the incident, Mr. Antoni merely stated scientific facts that have widespread support from empirical research. Society benefits if policy makers and analysts can make such statements without their remarks being smeared as “controversial.” There may be legitimate reasons to oppose Mr. Antoni’s nomination for the head of the Bureau of Labor Statistics, but his willingness to introduce mainstream scientific findings into policy conversations is not one of them.
References
Baye, A., & Monseur, C. (2016). Gender differences in variability and extreme scores in an international context. Large-scale Assessments in Education, 4(1). https://doi.org/10.1186/s40536-015-0015-x
Bogage, J. (2025, September 2). Trump’s BLS nominee discussed controversial theory on gender IQ with interns. The Washington Post. https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2025/09/02/trump-bls-nominee-gender-iq/
Deary, I. J., Thorpe, G., Wilson, V., Starr, J. M., & Whalley, L. J. (2003). Population sex differences in IQ at age 11: The Scottish mental survey 1932. Intelligence, 31(6), 533-542. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0160-2896(03)00053-9
Gray, H., Lyth, A., McKenna, C., Stothard, S., Tymms, P., & Copping, L. (2019). Sex differences in variability across nations in reading, mathematics and science: A meta-analytic extension of Baye & Monseur (2016). Large-scale Assessments in Education, 7(2). https://doi.org/10.1186/s40536-019-0070-9
Warne, R. T. (2025). Reasoning and intelligence online test, version 1.0. Riot IQ. https://riotiq.com